Insights

Where margin quietly leaks

Rows of shipping containers seen from above

Growing businesses rarely lose margin in one dramatic decision. They lose it in hundreds of small ones that nobody is looking at together.

Ask most B2B businesses what their margin is and they will give you a number from the management accounts. Ask what their margin is on a particular customer, delivered to a particular site, on a particular day, and the answer usually becomes much less certain.

That gap is where profit goes. Revenue grows, volumes grow, the team works harder — and profitability stays flat or falls. The business is busy, but not better off.

Price lists are rarely the problem

Most businesses have a sensible list price. The leakage happens between the list price and the money that finally arrives in the bank: the discounts, deals, terms, credits and costs that accumulate on the way.

In our work reviewing pricing for distribution and foodservice businesses, the same sources appear again and again:

  • Contract prices that never moved. Agreed in good faith, then left untouched while input costs rose. Each year the margin narrows a little further.
  • Discount creep. A one-off concession becomes the norm, then the starting point for the next negotiation.
  • Cost to serve ignored. A small order delivered urgently to a remote site is priced like a large planned drop on an existing route. They are not the same business.
  • Credits and returns. Short deliveries, damages and price disputes resolved with credit notes that nobody analyses.
  • Terms as hidden price. Extended payment terms, rebates and free delivery thresholds that cost real money but never appear on the price list.

Looking at the whole picture

A proper pricing review follows each customer from the list price to the net cash received, then sets that against the true cost of serving them. The result is often uncomfortable. Some of the largest accounts turn out to be among the least profitable. Some small, steady customers turn out to be carrying the business.

The value is not in the analysis alone. It is in what the business can then do with it:

  1. Reprice deliberately. Prioritise the accounts where the gap is widest and the relationship can bear an honest conversation.
  2. Price for cost to serve. Minimum order values, delivery charges or tiered pricing that reflect how much each order really costs to fulfil.
  3. Govern discounts. Clear authority levels, expiry dates on special terms, and visibility of who agreed what.
  4. Fix the operational causes. If credits are driven by picking errors or late deliveries, that is an operational problem with a pricing symptom.
  5. Build it into the system. Margin by customer and route should be visible every week, not discovered once a year.

Growth that pays

New customers and new markets matter. But winning more of the wrong business, on the wrong terms, only accelerates the leak. The most reliable route to profitable growth is often to understand the business already won — then grow from a foundation that makes money.

Our view

Pricing is not a finance exercise or a sales exercise. It sits across commercial strategy, operations and systems, which is why it so often falls between them. Bring the three together and margin stops leaking quietly.

If you are growing but profitability isn’t, we should talk.